Cat sitting is an easy gig. Essentially you just go to someone’s house and sit in it for an hour. You feed the cat, scoop the litterbox, and if the cat wants to cuddle, you cuddle. I cat-sit for this girl who lives 3 blocks from me named Meredith. Her cat is friendly, her apartment is nice, and she has an extensive DVD collection. All in all, this is an ideal job.
I bring this up because the first time I took care of Marshmallow (kitty’s name) Meredith recommended I check out season 1 of Dexter, which was part of the aforementioned extensive collection. Normally when someone recommends something to me I instantly tune them out. Not out of disrespect (well, not totally out of disrespect), but mainly because someone you know liking something isn’t necessarily a good indicator as to whether you’ll like it. And most of the time when someone recommends something they don’t really have you in mind. They’re recommending something because they like it. I’m guilty of this as well. It’s only natural when you really think something is awesome to assume that others will also. It’s like, “Man, Battlestar Galactica is incredible! Hey _____, you gotta check this out. You’ll love it!” Well, no, _____ might not love it, because _____ isn’t me. Whatever is in me that makes me like BSG might not be in him/her. You have to think about that before you recommend something to someone. Do you really have their interests at heart, or are you just trying to project your own interests onto someone else? Hard to say.
I have a few friends, a scant few mind you, who are really good at this, particularly with music. They know my inclinations, likes, and dislikes, and are able to provide recommendations accordingly. I’m always really impressed by that, because I struggle even to remember what kind of car my friends drive or what they do for a living. That could mean I’m self-absorbed, or it could just mean I’m unobservant. Or it could mean I’m unobservant because I’m self-absorbed. Regardless, its a shortcoming I’ve identified and am working on. With time, I will improve. Attempt to assess yourself honestly. Identify problems. Correct them. This is how we become better people.
OK, I started to sound like a bit of a know-it-all there, when in fact I know precious little, so lets reign it in (Reign of Fire?). This was supposed to be about Dexter. My point was, I don’t usually put much stock in recommendations, and at first I wasn’t inclined to give Dexter a chance. ‘What do I need with another TV show?” I thought, “I live in the city that never sleeps!”* But then I remembered how much I loved Michael C. Hall in Six Feet Under as David, the gay brother. He was awesome in that role, easily the best character on the show. And now he was playing a serial killer with a heart of gold? Yeah, I could get behind that. Dexter would be given a chance.
*I never actually though this. Ever. About anything.
This is where I’m supposed to either rave about how great the show is or declare it a total abomination, right? I’m not going to do that. Do I enjoy Dexter? Absolutely. It took me an average of three days to get through each of the first three seasons. Michael C. Hall alone is worth the price of admission. The problem is, he has to be. Everyone else on the show is terrible. Jennifer Carpenter, who plays his sister (and who he is married to in real life), has replaced Bridgitte Moynihan as the worst actress I’ve ever seen. To watch her is to hate her. Her character is supposed to be a sexy, foul-mouthed guys’ girl. You know, the kind you can drink beer and watch football with? The kind of girl every guy supposedly wants, but that no guy actually wants? Yeah, she plays that….with abandon!
The problem is, she also cries at least once per episode, and frequently says things like, “My dad and I never talked much. Not that I didn’t want to…” to virtual strangers. I think what they’re going for is a complex emotional dichotomy, but what they actually achieve is a woman who espouses all of the worst qualities women can have. And not only that, she stops being attractive around episode two. When you actually take a good look, you realize this “hot” chick is actually just an eating disorder with a big, aggressive face. Its gotten to the point where I can’t even stand to look at her. By the end of season two I was literally fast-forwarding through her scenes. I’m not exagerrating. Carpenter is that bad.
Another of the show’s myriad problems is its unbelievably simplistic police station backdrop. Most of the characters, including Dexter, work for the Miami police department. They, and apparently nobody else. You never so much as see any other police officers. In fact, even though these five or six characters all have very different jobs, they all work in the same room. Their desks are next to each other. To someone who has seen The Wire, this show plays like that South Park episode where the kids become detectives. A bunch of recycled cliches.
Still, Michael C. Hall overcomes. He takes a truly terrible cast and just puts them on his back. And he’s aided by a formula that works magic for the 1-hour drama: leave the viewer with fresh questions at the end of each episode. This formula has recently been used successfully on Lost and Heroes, and HBO pioneered it on Oz and the Sopranos. Dexter does it to perfection. At the end of every episode I’d pack a fresh batty and immediately be ready for the next one. The acting, dialogue, and setting may be total amateur hour, but the plot gets its hooks in you. Combine that with Hall’s undeniable brilliance, and you’ve got a show worthy of watching, despite its obvious flaws.
SPOILER ALERT!!!!
Jimmy Smits is in season 3. He and Dexter become pals. It’s incredible. When I first saw Smits I was like, “Oh fuck yeah! Here we go!”* He doesn’t disappoint.
*Those thoughts actually did cross my mind. In fact, I think I said those exact words out loud.
